GOYA – Still life with ram’s head Louvre (Paris)

This is a striking still life painting by Francisco Goya, titled Still Life with Rams Head. The composition is dominated by dark, rich tones and a stark, almost primal depiction of raw meat.

What I see:

In the foreground, resting on a wooden surface, are several cuts of meat. The most prominent is a large piece of what appears to be lamb ribs, foreshortened to emphasize its raw, fleshy nature. The marbling of fat against the deep red of the muscle is rendered with thick, expressive brushstrokes. To the left, the head of a ram is clearly visible. Its eye stares outwards with a vacant, beady gaze, its flesh a vivid pink and red, showing signs of recent butchery. Another piece of meat, possibly another cut of ribs, is partially visible in the background to the right. The background is a deep, oppressive black, which serves to isolate and intensify the visceral presence of the meat. The lighting is dramatic, casting strong highlights on the fatty parts of the meat and emphasizing the textures and forms.

Subtexts:

Goyas Still Life with Rams Head transcends a simple depiction of food. Several subtexts can be inferred:

• Mortality and the passage of time: The raw, butchered state of the meat, particularly the dead rams head, is a potent symbol of mortality. It confronts the viewer with the brutal reality of death and the ephemeral nature of life. The vacant stare of the ram can be interpreted as a reflection on the loss of consciousness and the stillness that follows death.
• The visceral and the primitive: Goyas unvarnished portrayal of raw flesh, with its textures and visceral details, taps into a primal human experience. It evokes a sense of the raw, untamed aspects of life and nature, stripping away any pretense of refinement.
• Social commentary or critique: Painted during a turbulent period in Spanish history, some interpretations suggest this still life could be a veiled commentary on the state of the nation. The dismembered and exposed meat might symbolize a broken or violated society, or the grim realities of war and suffering that Goya witnessed and often depicted. The starkness and lack of idealization could be a rejection of bourgeois comforts and a focus on the grim truths of existence.
• The artists inner turmoil: Goyas later works are often characterized by a profound sense of psychological depth and disquiet. This painting, with its grim subject matter and intense execution, could reflect the artists own anxieties, his confrontation with darkness, and his exploration of the darker aspects of the human condition.
• A subversion of traditional still life: In the tradition of still life painting, such subjects often symbolized abundance, domesticity, or Vanitas themes (the transience of earthly life). Goyas approach is raw, unsettling, and devoid of usual aesthetic pleasure, thus subverting expectations and challenging the viewer to look beyond the surface.

Overall, Still Life with Rams Head is a powerful and disturbing work that uses the seemingly mundane subject of raw meat to explore profound themes of life, death, and the darker realities of existence.